Evidence-Based Practice Network

Show Me The Evidence

The Blog of Lippincott's Evidence-Based Practice Network


Hierarchy of Evidence
     
     I am currently in a DNP program and one of our assignments was to complete a literature search on a topic. As I began my search through Ovid, ProQuest, EBSCO, Cochrane Library of Systematic Reviews, and other databases, I began to realize how easy it would be to become overwhelmed by the multitude of articles and studies published on the topic. I quickly became aware that not all information labeled as "evidence-based" was truly evidence-based. How many times do we see an original research article published in a peer-reviewed journal and the media begins making statements that there should be a change in healthcare practice. As healthcare professionals, we recognize that one original study is not sufficient to change practice. There is a hierarchy to evidence that all healthcare providers should be aware of. I have found two resources that have been especially helpful in determining hierarchy of evidence; one by R. Brian Haynes called the 6S Hierarchy of Preapprasied Evidence and one by Bernadette Melnyk and Ellen Fineout-Overholt called Hierarchy of Evidence for Interventional Studies

     Haynes 6S Model is based on a pyramid approach to evidence. At the base of the pyramid are original studies that are published in journals and at the peak of the pyramid are the computerized decison support systems that integrate evidence at point-of-care. In between these levels are synopses of studies and randomized controlled trials, meta-analyses, systematic reviews, and evidence-based clinical practice guidelines. The Hierarchy of Evidence for Interventional Studies by Melynk and Fineout-Overholt, lists the types of evidence in a table style and gives a description of each level of evidence. Being a visual learner, these formats brought clarity to where I was going in my literature search and helped me to determine which articles were of less importance.

     The next time you do a search on a topic, I suggest you pull out these two models to use as a guide to determine the hierarchy of evidence you are reviewing.

Posted by Anne Dabrow Woods on 10/14/2011 1:16:59 PM with 1 comments

Trackback URL: http://www.nursingcenter.com/evidencebasedpracticenetwork/trackback/2a447db2-3028-4eb9-bcf5-4bbc5781368b/Hierarchy-of-Evidence.aspx?culture=en-US

Comments
marbre
Thanks for these informations. This is a well written and well documented article.
1/17/2012 7:51:27 AM

Leave comment Subscribe



 Security code

Latest blog comments

2/18/2013
dhartz
Recently we went to solid color uniforms for all staff depe...

12/20/2012
rn nurse
This blog is very nice. i like it. please keep it up.

9/19/2012
Judy
Great article and your blog template is so cool. This is a...

5/21/2012
Louise Malbon-Reddix
Clearly,the patient's comfort is to be given priority h...

5/3/2012
Gayla Cauldwell
Treating physiologic response and patient specific response...

4/29/2012
Kate McGuigan
Hi, Thanks for this. I found this really helpful for an...

4/28/2012
hublot replica
I think the information you provide is very useful for me, ...

4/23/2012
Bulk sms
This post is really something special and more information ...

4/12/2012
Dr. Navarrete
me interesa el articulo completo

3/22/2012
Lisa Bonsall
Hi Catherine - thank your for your comment! Certification d...

|< <  1 2 3   > >|

About your comments

We welcome comments, discussion, curiosity, and debate. Let us know about your nursing lives and personal experiences. We reserve the right to moderate comments that are intended to sell something or that are inappropriate or hostile.

Disclaimer

Views expressed on this blog are solely those of the authors or persons quoted. They do not necessarily reflect Lippincott's NursingCenter.com's views or those of Wolters Kluwer Health/Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.