Keywords

African Americans, Benefits and limitations, Decision aid, Experimental design, Knowledge, Low income, Medically underserved, Prostate cancer screening, Solomon Four

 

Authors

  1. Weinrich, Sally P. PhD, RN, FAAN
  2. Seger, Rachelle BA
  3. Curtsinger, Tim BA
  4. Pumphrey, Gwen BA
  5. NeSmith, Elizabeth G. RN, PhD(c)
  6. Weinrich, Martin C. PhD

Abstract

There is a paucity of research on the effects of pretest measurement with prostate cancer screening. What effect does a pretest measurement have on posttest outcomes? This research reports knowledge of prostate cancer screening among men randomized to an Enhanced decision aid versus an Usual Care decision aid. Using a Solomon Four research design, there were a total of 198 men in 4 groups. Most of the sample was African American (78%), with a mean age of 52 years. The greatest posttest knowledge occurred with the Enhanced decision aid in contrast to the Usual Care. The Enhanced/Usual Care groups that had both a pretest and posttest and had received a previous digital rectal examination had the highest means (P = .015), with means of 9.1 and 7.0, respectively. Among men who had a previous digital rectal examination, the greatest increase in score occurred among men randomized to the Enhanced decision aid in contrast to the Usual Care decision aid, 2.9 versus 0.4 (P = .008). The outcome varied based on the status of (1) random group assignment of the Solomon Four design and (2) status of previous digital rectal examination. Implications for nurses include consideration 1 of a pretest to increase posttest knowledge scores.