View Entire Collection
By Clinical Topic
By State Requirement
Diabetes – Summer 2012
Future of Nursing Initiative
Heart Failure - Fall 2011
Influenza - Winter 2011
Nursing Ethics - Fall 2011
Trauma - Fall 2010
Traumatic Brain Injury - Fall 2010
Fluids & Electrolytes
In the next influenza pandemic, should a 60-year-old woman with heart disease and asthma receive a flu vaccine before a healthy 4-year-old? Proposed government guidelines would put the older woman ahead of the child. But two bioethicists at the National Institutes of Health argue that younger, healthier people should get preference.
The proposed government vaccine rationing plan is based on a desire to save the most lives. But writing in the journal Science, the two bioethicists advocate the "life-cycle principle," which is based on the notion that each person should have the chance to live through all stages of life.
Given the current state of vaccine manufacturing and distribution, rationing would be inevitable if a flu pandemic were to develop in the next few years. Everyone seems to agree that top priority for available vaccine should go to workers in vaccine factories and health care workers. But who's next?
Under the government's plan, priority goes to people over age 65 who have at least one high-risk health condition (such as asthma, heart disease, or emphysema). At the bottom of the pecking order? Healthy people ages 2 to 64.
The life-cycle principle turns this order on its head, giving preference to healthy people, with the youngest getting highest priority. The article authors propose modifying this approach with the public-order principle, which would also give priority to workers responsible for maintaining public safety and order, such as fire personnel, police, utility workers, and the military.
For more on government planning, go to http://www.pandemicflu.gov.
Source: Public Health: Who should get influenza vaccine when not all can?, Science, EJ Emanuel, A Wertheimer, May 12, 2006.
Sign up for our free enewsletters to stay up-to-date in your area of practice - or take a look at an archive of prior issues
Join our CESaver program to earn up to 100 contact hours for only $34.95
Explore a world of online resources
Back to Top