|This continuing-education offering is
sponsored by Nurses Service Organization
and provided by Lippincott Williams & Wilkins,
an accredited ANCC provider.
Nurses Guide to Malpractice: Module 2
|In an instant, a malpractice judgment can wipe out years, even a lifetime, of scrimping and saving. Whats more, it can seriously harm your personal and professional life. Here are ways to defend against such a disaster.|
PROTECTING yourself against malpractice is a little like practicing sound infection control: You do all you can to keep it from happening, but youre also prepared to minimize the damage if it does.
This doesnt mean that lawsuits lurk under every patients bed. Patients who file a claim may have suffered no more than a bad experience that a little more sensitivity would have prevented. (See Preventing Disturbing Perceptions.)
PREVENTING DISTURBING PERCEPTIONS
Although rarely grounds for legal action, anger at health care providers is a common element in many malpractice lawsuits. Patients or their families may feel ignored, manipulated, or dehumanized.
Frequently the issue is one of perception rather than fact; as a rule, health care providers dont intentionally treat their patients poorly. But the perception, if it didnt trigger the lawsuit, is probably an aggravating factor. Review these common patient perceptions and how you can prevent them.
Perception: Everyones in a hurry. No one ever takes a minute to ask how Im doing.
Prevention: Even if youre doing a necessary task (taking vital signs, for example), occasionally sit down with the patient while youre doing it. Use that relaxed connection to ask how the patients feeling.
Perception: The staff is so cold. They treat me as if Im some kind of checklist or a time card that they just punch in and out.
Prevention: Incorporate into your caregiving some simple social amenities, such as greetings, introductions, use of the patients name, and social touching.
Perception: I feel as if Ive lost all control over my life. People come whenever they please to interrupt me with some procedure. Ive got all this strange paraphernalia connected to me so I can hardly move.
Prevention: Orient the patient to staff, equipment, and unit routines, such as mealtimes. Involve the patient in his care planning.
Perception: No one knows who I am or seems to care. I hear people refer to me as the gallbladder in room 230 instead of by my name.
Prevention: Think of the patient as an individual rather than a diagnosis, even when youre not at the bedside. Always refer to him respectfully, within and outside his hearing range. Though you want to avoid prying, get the patient to share some personal information about family, work, interests, and the like.
Perception: No one respects my privacyor my private parts! It seems that anyone in white clothes can just pull back my covers without giving a thought to my embarrassment. And those short gowns with the open backI feel as though Im on display, like a piece of merchandise.
Prevention: As much as possible, respect the patients dignity and desire for privacy. Ask his permission before doing something that might be embarrassing and take every means to prevent unnecessary embarrassment. This includes draping appropriately for exams and procedures and reminding the patient not to get out of bed while wearing just a hospital gown.
To protect yourself against a malpractice lawsuit, you can use three powerful tools: documentation, compliance with policies and procedures, and malpractice insurance. Lets look at each of these more closely.
Not documented, not done
From a legal standpoint, the word documentation should probably have its first two letters capitalized. In the laws eyes, if you didnt document it, you didnt do it. And if you didnt do what you were supposed to do, you can be sued for negligence, another term for malpractice.
But simple documentation isnt enough; you need documentation with legal credibility. Such documentation can be your best defense if youre named in a lawsuit and may even help get you dismissed from the suit.
Documentation has legal credibility when its contemporaneous, accurate, truthful, and appropriate. Heres what those terms mean:
contemporaneous: documenting the care when you provide itinclude date, time, and so forth. (This is especially crucial during an emergency; see When Every Second Counts.)
WHEN EVERY SECOND COUNTS
An emergency may be the last situation where you want to take time documenting what youre doing. But document you must, for legal as well as clinical reasons.
One method is to designate a recorder as part of your emergency-response team. That way, you can call out what youre doing or observing, and the recorder jots it down. Dont use the recorder for any other tasks, such as getting supplies.
Minute-by-minute documentation is especially important because time can seem to expand or contract during an emergency. If you have a recorder, be sure this person has access to an easily readable clock. If you dont have a recorder, do your best to keep a running log rather than rely on your memory later on; courts dont look kindly on after-the-fact reconstruction.
Here are some items that call for timed documentation in an emergency:
What was the patients condition prior to the emergency?
What was his condition when the emergency began?
When did the emergency occur?
When did intervention begin?
When was the family notified?
What interventions were provided?
How did the patient respond?
accurate: documenting exactly what you did
truthful: documenting only what you actually did or observed (no more, no less)
appropriate: documenting only what youd be comfortable showing in public.
Those guidelines may appear obvious, but consider the danger in not following them.
Contemporaneous. A medication thats not immediately documented might be given again by another nurse, resulting in an overdose. Chart that medications are given immediately. Delayed documentation of accurate intake and output could result in dehydration. Not documenting allergies can produce unexpected adverse reactions.
Accurate. If you chart a medication amount thats less than what you administered, for example, another nurse might notice the difference and administer an additional amount, creating the possibility for a toxic or even deadly overdose.
Truthful. Documenting a treatment you didnt provide has double damages; it exposes the patient to the suffering the treatment was intended to alleviate, and it exposes you to the charge of fraud because payment will be required from the patients insurance company for a medication he didnt receive.
Appropriate. Placing in the chart judgmental labels such as lazy or sneaky can seem innocent enough at the nurses station. But think of their impact when the chart is projected onto a screen in a courtroom and youre asked to explain those terms. (For a detailed list of practical ways to apply these four characteristics, see Dos and Donts for Legally Credible Documentation.)
DOS AND DONTS FOR LEGALLY CREDIBLE DOCUMENTATION
DO chart time, route, dose, and response to medications.
DO chart any p.r.n. medication you give, plus how it helped or didnt help.
DO chart each time you phone a health care provider, even if you dont get through; include the exact time and, if you do get through, the details of your message and the health care providers response.
DO read a verbal order back to the prescriber after youve charted it and read the name on the chart to confirm patient identity.
DO have the prescriber countersign the verbal order within the policy time limit.
DONT chart a verbal order unless you heard it yourself.
Formal issues in charting
DO check that you have the correct patients chart before you start writing.
DO make sure each page has the patients name and the date on it.
DO chart an action at the time you perform it; contemporaneous notes are the most credible.
DO write late entry, along with the date and time, if you forgot to document something contemporaneously.
DO correct your charting mistake according to your facilitys policies and procedures.
DO write to reflect an organized process: from assessment, to planning, to intervention, to evaluation.
DO write legibly.
DO write concise, clear notes reflecting facts.
DO use only those abbreviations or initials that your facility accepts (for example, I&O).
DO write specific, accurate descriptions (for example, bright red blood, 18-inch diameter on linens from wound instead of bed soaked or a large amount).
DONT use shorthand.
DONT use vague expressions, such as a good shift, appears, or seems.
DONT write prejudicial or sarcastic statements.
DONT blanket chart or prechart. Charting something you didnt do is fraud and can be prosecuted as a criminal offense.
DONT chart a symptom without also charting your intervention and the patients true response.
Quality issues in charting
DO chart solutions as well as problems.
DO document only your own observations: what you see, hear, feel, or smell.
DO write frequently enough so youre demonstrating ongoing care. Intervals will vary, depending on your facility (for example, intensive care versus long-term care).
DO chart routine activities, such as turned every 2 hours.
DO chart precautions and preventive measures, such as putting side rails up.
DO chart the circumstances of errors and how they were handled on the appropriate form.
DO chart and report patient refusals.
DO chart your efforts to help a patient understand.
DO chart patient and family teaching and response.
DO chart all referrals and support efforts.
DONT chart vague or ambiguous orders. Ask the prescriber (not another caregiver) for clarification or verification.
DONT postpone charting until the end of the shift when you must rely on memory and may run out of time.
DONT ever alter a record; this is a criminal act.
DONT document what someone else said they heard, saw, felt, smelled, or did unless this information is crucial; in which case, quote the statement and give the source.
DONT write about administrative problems (for example, because of understaffing).
DONT write excuses, such as medication not given because not available; instead, state why the intervention wasnt performed and what you did to make up for it.
DONT chart that an incident report was filled out.
Legally credible documentation is an accurate record of both the care your patient received and your competence in providing that care. It tells anyone who reads it that you did all you were expected to do.
Charting by exception is a type of documentation that can be difficult to defend. In this case, investigators would review the entire patient record to see if they could piece together the care given.
Getting with the policy
The second nursing tool, policies and procedures, provides a safety zone that ultimately protects you from suffering the damage of a nursing malpractice lawsuit. They do this in various ways:
They set concrete, specific standards for providing quality care and for interacting appropriately with patients, families, and staff.
They establish the structures and controls that constitute your organizations chain of command and responsibility.
They guide you in determining whats expected of you as an employee in your workplace.
Generally, you can find these policies and procedures either in your nursing unit or elsewhere in your facility.
Of course, protecting you from a malpractice lawsuit isnt the immediate goal of policies and procedures. Nor is it the main reason why nurses and other professionals comply with them.
First and foremost, compliance with policies and procedures helps ensure a safe environment that prevents injury to patients and staff. It guides the staff in dealing with issues such as advance directives. Compliance also helps ensure that government and professional requirements are met. These requirements include, for example, the Environmental Protection Agencys protocol for disposal of hazardous medical waste.
Finally, although compliance with policies and procedures cant prevent malpractice lawsuits, it helps reduce their number. When lawsuits do occur, a record of compliance can go a long way toward eliminating or mitigating staff liability.
Despite their advantages, policies and procedures can be annoying and labor-intensiveand youre probably tempted to sidestep or circumvent them occasionally. Even though it seems perfectly safe, dont do it. What looks like an innocent bending of the rules can open the door to problems that affect you deeply and directly.
For one thing, any act of noncompliance can be construed as a breach of the standard of care. Into that breach can seep lawsuits from patients, staff, and even casual visitors. As a direct care provider, your chances of being named in some of those challenges are greater than others.
For another, noncompliance with policies and procedures can also lead to losses resulting from actions taken by regulators, reimbursers, and accreditors. State health departments regularly inspect for compliance with licensure and Medicaid reimbursement standards, as does the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. The Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations inspects for compliance with accreditation standards. Anything that jeopardizes this delicate balance of complying and caregiving can lead to revoked licenses, terminated reimbursement, dried up credit, and large cash outlays for judicial appeals. All of this may sound removed from day-to-day nursing, but eventually it can result in such consequences as reduced wages or loss of your job or license.
With so much riding on a facilitys policies and procedures, you can see why theyve become the responsibility of all employees. Heres what this means for you as a nurse.
Make sure that you know the policies and procedures that apply to you and your practice, follow them meticulously, and assist others in knowing and following them.
If you cause or observe an infraction, either correct it directly yourself or notify those responsible for correcting it.
Take an active part in keeping your facilitys policies and procedures current.
This last point is crucial. Lawsuits are based on the national standard of carea broadly accepted reasonable practice standard for nursing care. If your facilitys policies and procedures are below that standard, following them doesnt protect you from a charge of malpractice. Youre expected to know what the national standard is and to use good nursing judgment in following it, even if this means departing from your facilitys policies and procedures.
To ensure that youre not put in the vulnerable position of having to second-guess your facility, do everything you can to monitor and maintain its policies and procedures. Become active in committees that develop policies and procedures, and notify your risk manager or nurse-manager if your facilitys policies and procedures are below the national standard of care (see Making Policies and Procedures Work). Policies should be reviewed and updated every 2 years.
MAKING POLICIES AND PROCEDURES WORK
With the critical role that policies and procedures play in the legal aspects of nursing, keeping them current and realistic should be every nurses concern. If you have input into the review process, be sure that the following considerations receive proper attention:
As a standard against which supervisory and staff nurses will be judged in the event of a lawsuit or a complaint to regulatory agencies, policies and procedures should demonstrate concurrence with legal and regulatory standards.
Staff nurses should have input into the development of policies and procedures to ensure that theyre reality-based. For example, assessing vital signs every 5 minutes postoperatively is an admirable goal but, before committing to any policy, consider whether its appropriate in all cases and whether you can consistently meet that standard.
Implementation of new or modified policies and procedures should include staff-development sessions, plus a signed acknowledgment that the education was received and understood.
Besides complying with policies and procedures, youre also required to see that appropriate regulatory agencies are notified whenever specific standards arent followed. You probably know, for example, that many states require reporting suspected patient abuse or neglect. But as part of your role as patient advocate, most states require a licensed nurse to report when another professional breaches a standard of practice that could result in action by a licensure board. This means, for example, that you may have a duty to report observing another licensed professional give care while intoxicated or performing a task thats beyond the scope of her license.
If you fail to make a required report, you may do more than increase the risk of injury to a patient or colleagueyou may also jeopardize your own nursing license. You need not, of course, report directly to the regulatory agency. Rather, you may make your report to the appropriate authorities within your nursing administration. Theyll determine who should notify the agency. Follow up by checking with the administration that the report was filed.
If you work in a hospital or other health care facility, your first question might be, Arent I covered by the facilitys insurance? The answer is: more than likelybut. The facility insurance covers you only during the hours when youre working as a salaried employee of the facility and only when youre functioning within the course and scope of your duties as an employee. Also, you wont be the named insured; the facility will be. Whats more, without reviewing the facilitys policy, you wont know how much coverage you have.
If, however, youre sued for a professional service you performed outside of workperhaps doing volunteer work and injuring a patientyoure not covered. Youre also not covered if you do something at work that exceeds the scope of your dutiesfor example, performing an action that isnt allowed by your facilitys policies and procedures.
Even if youre covered by your facilitys insurance, having your own insurance as well provides advantages. It covers you 24 hours a day and while youre performing activities that arent work-related (such as giving an injection to a neighbor).
Another advantage is that your insurance may provide coverage if the facility sues you for repayment of damages from a medical malpractice claim that involves your negligence (a process referred to as indemnification or subrogation). Finally, youll have your own attorney looking out for your best interest. Thatll be especially important if your interests and your employers interests are in conflict and you suddenly find yourself excluded from the facilitys malpractice insurance policy.
Malpractice insurance policies for nurses provide either claims-made or occurrence coverage. Claims-made policies provide coverage for incidents that (1) occur from the effective date of the policy through the date the policy is terminated, and (2) are reported to the insurance company during the policy period (or during the tail, which well define in a minute).
To be covered for acts that take place outside the timeframe of a claims-made policy, youd need to purchase additional coverage. One type of additional coverage is called prior acts or nose coverage. This protects against claims arising from incidents that happened before the inception or effective date of a policy.
The second type is called tail or extended reporting period coverage. An uninterrupted extension of the insurance policy period, this provides protection for covered claims that arise out of incidents that occurred during the policy period, up to the date the policy ended. The claims must be reported to the insurance company during the tail period, which can be for a set period or an unlimited time, depending on the option selected.
This option is important because states vary in how much time they allow for a claim to be filed; it can be 1 to 3 years and even longer if a minor is involved. Facilities usually have claims-made coverage, but it may not include nose or tail coverage.
Occurrence policies cover any incident that occurs during the policy period regardless of when the claim is filed or whether the policy is still in effect. That means it provides long-term protection for any covered claim that may arise at any time in the futureup to the limits of the policy in force at the time of the incident that led to the claim.
For both types of policies, make sure that you dont allow gaps in coverage to occur. A gap can occur, for example, if you let your policy expire and dont renew your insurance. It can also occur if you fail to purchase tail coverage when your claims-made policy coverage ends.
If there is a gap in your insurance, youre referred to as unprotected, or bare. You wont have coverage to pay for defense costs if youre sued. And the insurance company wont pay the damage award, which means that the plaintiff (injured party) can attack your personal assets.
Here are some key questions you should ask in considering an individual insurance policy:
How does it define a claim? The definition can be as vague as a report of an incident that could result in a lawsuit or complaint or as precise as receipt by the insured, while the policy is in effect, of a demand for money or services based on an alleged medical incident.
Be sure the definition includes when you must report a claim. If a claim isnt reported in what the policy considers a timely fashion, it may not be covered. (Keep in mind that your policy goes into effect on the date the insurer accepts your application for coverage, not the date you sign or mail the application. Unless you have nose coverage on a claims-made policy, or were covered by an occurrence policy at the time of the incident, you wont be covered for any acts before the acceptance date.)
Finally, you might be covered just for certain claims. If the policy contains a damages only limitation, the insurance company will pay only if the nurse is sued for money damages. The insurance company wont cover lawsuits intended to force the nurse to stop performing certain actions (such as those outside the nursing scope of practice or outside the facilitys policies and procedures). Those actions that arent routinely covered are called specific performance or injunctive relief actions.
What are the limits of liability? Liability limits are generally expressed as two amountsfor example, $1 million/$6 million. The first number reflects the maximum amount of protection for any single claim (per occurrence); the second, the total amount that can be paid for all claims during each year of the policy (annual aggregate).
How much liability coverage should you have? Two determining factors are your assets and your professional level. A third involves state laws that may cap or limit the awards plaintiffs can receive for medical negligence cases.
The greater your assets, the greater your personal risk. Those assets include your savings, properties, wages, and inheritances. Any or all of them can be attached at either their present or future levels. (In most states, money and property held jointly by spousesdesignated tenets by entiretiescant be attached.)
Generally, increased management responsibility or independence of practice brings increased risk of liability. This means that a director of nursing, nursing supervisor, or nurse-educator is at greater risk than a staff nurse. Among the specialty practices that increase your risk are nurse practitioner, certified registered nurse-anesthetist, and nurse-midwife. (As well see, these also require special insurance.)
A cap on damage awards limits the amount of money the insurance company would be liable for if the patient recovers for damages. Depending on your state law, you may be required to pay an added insurance premium to a state fund to cap the damage award and limit the amount of money the insurance company would be liable for.
How are defense costs handled? These costs include more than lawyers fees. They also include all costs related to investigating and defending a claim, such as legal fees, travel, photocopying, expert witnesses, transcription fees, and so on.
Your policy will cover defense costs in one of two ways: inside your limits of liability or in addition to those limits. Those covered inside your limits wont be paid if they exceed the amount of your coverage, which can happen with a high judgment against you. Those covered in addition to your limits will be paid as long as the judgment against you doesnt exceed your liability. The latter arrangement offers the maximum protection.
What are the exclusions? Common exclusions in a standard nurses professional liability insurance policy include nurse practitioner, nurse-midwife, nurse-anesthetist, emergency medical technician, physician assistant or surgeons assistant, and X-ray therapist. Also excluded is any liability you may have as a proprietor, superintendent, executive, or administrative officer or director of a hospital, nursing or convalescent home, lab, or psychiatric facility. Special policies are available for these exclusions.
Besides these, other common exclusions include patient sexual abuse, injury caused while under the influence of drugs or alcohol, criminal activity, claims not seeking money damages, transmission of acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) from provider to patient, and punitive damages (damages awarded to punish the defendant for an outrageous or egregious act).
Besides insurance against malpractice claims, you may also want to consider carrying disciplinary defense insurance. Your personal malpractice insurance may not provide this kind of coverage.
Disciplinary defense insurance protects you against the financial and professional setbacks associated with having to appear at a disciplinary hearing. Allegations can be brought against you by any third party and, whether youre justly or unjustly accused, you may have to appear before a state nursing board to defend the allegations against your nursing license. Allegations that may result in disciplinary hearings can range from drug use to inappropriate medication administration to falsification of documents.
If youre called to appear before a state nursing board to defend your license, youll want to have a lawyer well versed in the disciplinary process. This may result in legal fees and expenses, as well as lost income while you attend the hearing. A relatively new form of insurance, disciplinary defense insurance can provide reimbursement for legal fees, wage loss, travel, food, lodging, and other costs.
The best defense
In the best of all possible worlds, legally credible documentation and compliance with policies and procedures would be the only defenses youd need against a lawsuit. But because youre human and may make mistakes, and because todays health delivery system is increasingly complex, relying only on these defenses is at best a dream, at worst a denial. Prevention plus protection is a more realistic response.
Iyer, P.: Nursing Documentation, in Nursing Malpractice, 2nd edition, P. Iyer (ed). Tucson, Ariz., Lawyers & Judges Publishing Co., 2001.
Iyer, P., and Camp, N.: Nursing Documentation: A Nursing Process Approach, 3rd edition. St. Louis, Mosby Year-Book, 1999.
OKeefe, M. (ed): Nursing Practice and the Law: Avoiding Malpractice and Other Legal Risks. Philadelphia, F.A. Davis, 2001.
Tonia Dandry Aiken, RN, BSN, JD, president and chief executive officer, RN Development, Inc., New Orleans, La., served as nursing/legal consultant for this series. She has served as a consultant and speaker for NSO.